I am looking for a solid oak hardwood floor, 3 1/2", not too shiny with square edges and the least amount of variations. I am down to these four choices:

Century Arlington Oak
Columbia Thorton Oak Honey
Mohawk Woodleigh Oak Golden
Armstrong Westchester Plank, spice

Any thoughts?

Century and Columbia are both owned by Mohawk but I would go with either of those over the Mohawk line. Westchester is under the Bruce line but yes owned by Armstrong. And They are all 3 1/4 not 3 1/2 and none of the 4 have square edges the all have bevels.

Dang, I thought this was about basketball. sigh Go AZ Wildcats!!!